By Akram Alami, Partner, Bain & Company Middle East and Jean-Charles van den Branden, Partner, Bain & Company Brussels
Environmental, social, and corporate governance (ESG) is rapidly becoming front of mind for regulators, investors, customers, and employees—and it is rising to the top of corporate agendas as well. Many now view a well-devised corporate ESG strategy as a positive indicator for long-term revenue growth.
In our recent global survey of 281 M&A executives, 65% expect their own company's focus on ESG to increase over the next three years. This view extends to M&A. More than half of surveyed respondents either see ESG leadership as justifying higher deal valuations or expect this to be the case in the future, indicating a need for buyers to appropriately assess and value their targets' ESG performance.
But are corporate buyers accounting for ESG in their M&A process today?
Not yet, according to our survey. Only 11% of respondents say they extensively assess ESG during the deal-making process on a regular basis. In fact, out of 10 elements of the corporate M&A process, ESG was the least-emphasized dimension. Many are struggling to determine how to embed the process of assessing the ESG implications of an acquisition into their M&A strategy.
Some companies are ahead on this curve. By incorporating ESG into their M&A process, they have set themselves up with an advantage in pursuing value creation opportunities and a head start in meeting their ESG imperatives.
By beginning to unlock ESG as an M&A priority and a factor in delivering deal value, these companies move ahead of the majority of companies that have yet to evolve their M&A models to account for the growing sophistication of ESG. They've discovered that the traditional check-the-box approach to sustainability issues falls short. When assessing targets, they dig deeper on issues ranging from greenhouse gas emissions to DEI, and from business ethics to supply chains.
Linking corporate ESG strategy to M&A
Success in this arena begins by linking overarching corporate ESG strategy to M&A strategy. It means making sustainability a part of each deal thesis. It means using corporate priorities as a benchmark to assess each potential deal and find assets that will advance existing ESG initiatives as well as create economic value.
This value can come from multiple sources. For instance, in the consumer products industry, 68% of our surveyed executives see ESG's value in helping them gain share by improving their brand image to appeal to changing consumer preferences. Leaders in the energy sector, meanwhile, more commonly cite ESG initiatives for helping them meet requirements or expectations of investors and financiers to lower the cost of capital. Across industries, ESG measures can also add value by helping manage costs (e.g., waste reduction) or by helping attract and retain top talent—a particularly critical goal in today's competitive talent environment.
Of course, not every asset will advance an underlying ESG goal, and other business rationales will often justify pursuing a given asset, regardless of the ESG footprint. Even in such situations, performing diligence on a target's ESG record is critical to underwriting the deal. There may be real financial costs that the buyer will incur to integrate and advance the target's ESG capabilities up to the acquirer's standards, for example.
The maturity and urgency of the ESG imperative varies by industry, company, and even by specific deal. As a result, it's important that companies distinguish between ESG-motivated and ESG-conscious M&A.
ESG-motivated deals are pursued explicitly to advance the buyer's ESG agenda. Perhaps the most visible examples are in carbon-intensive industries. M&A is a driving force in the energy sector's transition to renewable sources of power. As we explore in“Energy and Natural Resources M&A: Deals to Deliver the Energy Transition,” incumbents use M&A to reposition their portfolios around sustainable energy alternatives faster than they could be built organically. In consumer products, the shift from animal- to plant-based proteins has prompted its own surge in M&A and partnerships.
Meanwhile, ESG-conscious M&A incorporates an ESG angle across the M&A value chain, even if the motivating deal thesis is not ESG related. For example, acquirers may perform due diligence to determine if a target's carbon footprint is aligned with the acquirer's sustainability goals, unrelated to the deal rationale. Companies seeking transparent and socially conscious supply chains will give extra scrutiny to a potential acquisition's vendor base. Such ESG-conscious thinking is gaining popularity across industries, though different sectors will place emphasis on different ESG topics.
Our survey of executives found that the mix of deal type varies across industries. For example, while energy sector executives report that the plurality of deals within their industry are ESG motivated, most other industries see ESG-conscious M&A as far more relevant to their current deal makeup.
To strengthen their ESG efforts in M&A, we recommend buyers ask themselves several key questions that will guide the integration of ESG into the deal-making process.
- Strategy: What are the implications of our corporate ESG agenda on our M&A strategy? How will the board weigh ESG considerations when evaluating deals?
- Diligence: What are the material ESG issues for this deal, and how does the target perform in those areas? What are the potential risks and improvements to our overall ESG position and competitiveness? How do we evolve our diligence playbook to answer these questions? How do ESG considerations impact the value creation plan for this asset?
- Integration: How does ESG factor into our integration thesis? What governance and resourcing is required to ensure ESG objectives and value creation initiatives are met (either for improving the target's ESG performance or leveraging the target's strengths to improve our own ESG performance)? What are the specific initiatives to unlock the ESG value creation opportunities?
These questions may be tough to answer, but by asking them early, companies set themselves up to address the ESG imperative for everyone's benefit as they make the M&A moves that will boost their performance.
About Bain & Company
Bain & Company is a global consultancy that helps the world's most ambitious change makers define the future.
Across 63 offices in 38 countries, we work alongside our clients as one team with a shared ambition to achieve extraordinary results, outperform the competition, and redefine industries. We complement our tailored, integrated expertise with a vibrant ecosystem of digital innovators to deliver better, faster, and more enduring outcomes. Our 10-year commitment to invest more than $1 billion in pro bono services brings our talent, expertise, and insight to organizations tackling today's urgent challenges in education, racial equity, social justice, economic development, and the environment. We earned a gold rating from EcoVadis, the leading platform for environmental, social, and ethical performance ratings for global supply chains, putting us in the top 2% of all companies. Since our founding in 1973, we have measured our success by the success of our clients, and we proudly maintain the highest level of client advocacy in the industry.
MENAFN provides the information “as is” without warranty of any kind. We do not accept any responsibility or liability for the accuracy, content, images, videos, licenses, completeness, legality, or reliability of the information contained in this article. If you have any complaints or copyright issues related to this article, kindly contact the provider above.