The No-State Solution Becomes More And More Real

Israel's army has advanced its execution of the“Gaza Nakba.” In the early stage of the attack, Israel told Palestinian civilians to move south within the Strip, along Salah al-Din Road, the north-south axis in this 40-kilometer-long area of Palestine that holds 2.3 million Palestinians. The Israelis said they would largely attack northern Gaza, particularly Gaza City.

Around 1.5 million Palestinians moved from the northern part of Gaza to the south, the Israelis having told them repeatedly that this would be a safe zone. Those who stayed experienced a level of bombardment not seen in Gaza in the past, which has been pummeled by the Israelis on a punctual basis since 2006 (the current war including deadly air strikes against highly congested refugee camps, such as Jabalia).

In late November, five weeks into their brutal bombing in the north, Israel aircraft intensified the bombing of Gaza's second-largest city, Khan Younis, and began ground operations in the areas where they had told civilians to take shelter. By the first week of December, Israeli tanks surrounded Khan Younis, and Israeli aircraft began to bomb small towns in the southern part of Gaza.

Having pushed 1.8 Palestinians into the south, the Israelis now began to bomb that part of Gaza. Meanwhile, Israel's refusal to allow sufficient humanitarian aid to enter Gaza meant that nine out of 10 Palestinians are living without food for days on end (some told the UN World Food Program that they had not eaten in 10 days).

This total war by Israel has pushed the majority of Palestinians in Gaza down toward the Egyptian border. Under cover of this war, the Israelis have also moved aggressively into the West Bank to deepen the Permanent Nakba in that part of the Occupied Palestinian Territory.

As early as October 18, long before the Israeli forces moved toward Khan Younis, the Israel military tweeted that it“orders Gaza residents to move to the humanitarian zone in the area of Al-Mawasi.” Three days later, the Israeli military said the Palestinians must move“south of Wadi Gaza” and go to the“humanitarian area in Mawasi.”

Those who went to this small enclave (8.55 square kilometers) found it without any services – including no Internet – and found that even here the Israelis were firing their weapons nearby.

Mohammed Ghanem, who had lived near Al-Shifa Hospital in northern Gaza, said Al-Mawasi was“neither humane nor safe.”

Palestinians in southern Gaza now hope that they can get out before the Israeli bombs find them. The death toll is now in excess of 18,000 dead. As one Palestinian friend wrote in a text,“If we do not leave our homes and go into exile, we will get killed here.”

He sent this text just when confirmation arrived that more Palestinians have been pushed out of their homes and killed since October 7 than in the Nakba of 1948.“This is the Second Nakba,” he said to me from near the border between Gaza and Egypt.

The ghastly Israeli attack on the Palestinians of Gaza provoked a call for a ceasefire from the second week of October. Israel's immense firepower – provided by Western countries (especially the United Kingdom and the United States) – was used indiscriminately against a people who live in congested areas of Gaza.

Images of that violence flooded social media and even broadcast news, which could not ignore what was happening. These images overcame all the attempts by the Israeli government and its Western backers to justify their actions.

Tens of millions of people joined various forms of protests across the world, but significantly in the Western states that back Israel, bravely confronting governments that tried to portray their solidarity with the Palestinians – unsuccessfully – as anti-Semitism.

This attack was a cynical attempt to use the actual and horrible existence of anti-Semitism to malign the protests. It did not work. The call for a full-scale ceasefire increased, putting pressure on governments around the world to act.

On December 8, the United Arab Emirates put a“brief, simple, and crucial” resolution for a ceasefire (the words are from UAE Ambassador to the UN Mohamed Issa Abushahab).

UN Secretary General António Guterres invoked Article 99 of the Charter, which allows him to underscore the importance of an event through“preventive diplomacy” (the article has only been used three times previously, over the conflicts in the Republic of Congo in 1960, Iran in 1979, and Lebanon in 1989). Almost a hundred member states of the UN backed the UAE resolution.

Sign up for one of our free newsletters

• The Daily Report Start your day right with Asia Times' top stories
• AT Weekly Report A weekly roundup of Asia Times' most-read stories

“The people of Gaza are being told to move like human pinballs – ricocheting between ever-smaller slivers of the south, without any of the basics for survival,” Guterres told the UN Security Council.“Nowhere in Gaza is safe.”

Thirteen members of the Security Council voted for it, including France, while the United Kingdom abstained. Only US Deputy Ambassador Robert Wood raised his hand to veto the resolution.

Four days later, on December 12, the Egyptians tabled much the same resolution in the UN General Assembly, where Assembly President Dennis Francis (of Trinidad and Tobago) said ,“We have one singular priority – only one – to save lives. Stop this violence now.” The vote was overwhelming : 153 countries voted for the resolution, 10 voted against it, and 23 abstained.

It is instructive to see which countries voted against the ceasefire: Austria, the Czech Republic, Guatemala, Israel, Liberia, Micronesia, Nauru, Papua New Guinea, Paraguay, and the United States.

Many European countries – from Bulgaria to the United Kingdom – abstained. But matters are complex. Even Ukraine did not vote with Israel on this resolution. It abstained.

The US veto in the Security Council and the votes against in the General Assembly are in effect votes for the Permanent Nakba of the Palestinian people, the No-State Solution. At least, that is how they will be read across the world, not only in al-Mawasi, as the bombs get closer, but also in the demonstrations from New York to Jakarta.

Vijay Prashad is an Indian historian, editor, and journalist. He is a writing fellow and chief correspondent at Globetrotter, which provided this article to Asia Times. He is an editor of LeftWord Books and the director of Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research .

Like this:Like Loading...