Ukraine Peace Summit Failed To Meet 'Fairytale' Expectations

(MENAFN- Swissinfo) The world's media has given a mixed reaction to the Swiss-hosted Ukraine peace conference, which produced a joint communiqué that was signed by most delegates but was rejected by several key countries.

This content was published on June 17, 2024 - 13:42 4 minutes

When not covering fintech, cryptocurrencies, blockchain, banks and trade, swissinfo's business correspondent can be found playing cricket on various grounds in Switzerland - including the frozen lake of St Moritz.

• More from this auth
• English Departme

• Français fr Le sommet sur la paix en Ukraine n'a pas répondu aux attentes ((de contes de fées)) Read more: Le sommet sur la paix en Ukraine n'a pas répondu aux attentes ((de contes de fées)
• Italiano it La Conferenza sulla pace in Ucraina non ha soddisfatto le“fiabesche” aspettative Read more: La Conferenza sulla pace in Ucraina non ha soddisfatto le“fiabesche” aspettativ
• 日本語 ja ウクライナ平和サミット 「おとぎ話」のような期待に応えられず Read more: ウクライナ平和サミット 「おとぎ話」のような期待に応えられす

The Bürgenstock declaration, backed by 84 of the countries and organisations in attendance, laid the blame of the conflict squarely at the door of Russia.

Check out our selection of newsletters. Subscribe here .

But the statement failed to attract support from several attendees, including India, South Africa, Saudi Arabia, Mexico and Brazil. Russia and China were not present at the two-day conference in central Switzerland.

+ Why China shunned Swiss-led Ukraine peace summit

The media in Russia and Ukraine unsurprisingly delivered conflicting verdicts on the result of the summit. The final communiqué contained significant changes from the initial draft, reported the Ukrainian newspaper European Pravda.

“In a short period of time it was radically revised, correcting key problems,” the newspaper wrote.“The updated draft turned out to be quite acceptable for Ukraine. Its authors (finally!) found the courage to call the war 'Russian aggression'.”

Russia state-controlled media was less complimentary, echoing the previously stated view of the Kremlin.

“The outcome of the peace summit in Switzerland, even to a layperson's eye, seems dubious,” said the Russian newspaper MK.

'Diplomatic tightrope walk'

One of the non-signatories, South Africa, took issue with Israel's participation at the peace summit despite being accused of war crimes and human rights violations by a United Nations Human Rights Council commission.

+ How to find path to peace in Ukraine

The Daily Maverick quoted South Africa's lead delegate, Sydney Mufamadi, as saying that this“failure to uniformly and fairly implement international law in all conflict situations globally weakens the normative framework of international accountability and makes the world less safe for all”.

Colombian President Gustavo Petro, pulled out of the Bürgenstock summit at the last moment, notes the Spanish newspaper El País. Petro took to the social media platform X on Saturday to complain that the summit's“conclusions are already predetermined” by“blocs of countries for war”.

The Indian Express interpreted India's refusal to sign the declaration as another sign of“New Delhi's diplomatic tightrope walk that has marked its diplomacy since the war began”. Several Indian media made note of India's reliance on Russia for weapons and cut-price oil imports.

'Dangerous illusion'

Above all else, Bürgenstock reinforced the trenchant divide between the United States and Europe on one side and the China-led“Global South” nations.“The division of the international community remained unresolved, and the difficulty of achieving peace was once again exposed,” noted the Japanese newspaper Mainichi Shimbun.

The Swiss media also focused on the lack of global consensus, which was laid bare by the summit's joint communiqué.

“At the fairytale Bürgenstock luxury hotel this weekend people were indulging in the no-less fairytale idea that a diplomatic solution to the conflict could somehow be found. That is a dangerous illusion,” reported the Blick newspaper.

“India is missing. Saudi Arabia is missing. Mexico is missing. South Africa is missing,” stated Der Bund.“Unity and solidarity were invoked at the beginning of the Bürgenstock conference – but when it came to the decisive final document, the very countries in whom so much hope was placed went missing.”

Edited by Balz Rigendinger/ts

External Content Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again. Almost finished... We need to confirm your email address. To complete the subscription process, please click the link in the email we just sent you. Daily news

Get the most important news from Switzerland in your inbox.

Daily

Email

The SBC Privacy Policy provides additional information on how your data is processed.

I consent to the use of my data for the SWI swissinfo newsletter.

Deeply Read More Science Switzerland says it can't afford to take part in Copernicus programme Read more: Switzerland says it can't afford to take part in Copernicus programm More Workplace Switzerland How Switzerland plans to tackle its labour shortage Read more: How Switzerland plans to tackle its labour shortag More Culture Switzerland wins Eurovision Song Contest 2024 Read more: Switzerland wins Eurovision Song Contest 202 More Workplace Switzerland Owning a home is becoming increasingly difficult in Switzerland Read more: Owning a home is becoming increasingly difficult in Switzerlan More Life & Aging Swiss village of Lauterbrunnen mulls Venice-style tourist entry charge Read more: Swiss village of Lauterbrunnen mulls Venice-style tourist entry charge Most Discussed More Debate Hosted by: Katy Romy June 9 votes in Switzerland: how can healthcare costs be reined in?

On June 9, Swiss voters decided on two initiatives aimed at capping the cost of healthcare in the country. Have your say on the issue here.

Join the discussi Jun 5, 2024 68 Likes 78 Comments View the discussi More Debate Hosted by: Bruno Kaufmann How can democracy be enhanced in schools?

How can we improve democracy education to better prepare students for civic engagement?

Join the discussi May 24, 2024 1 Likes 34 Comments View the discussi More Debate Hosted by: Elena Servettaz Should politics be kept out of sporting and cultural events?

Cultural and sporting events are being increasingly politicised. Is this a problem?

Join the discussi May 28, 2024 7 Likes 15 Comments View the discussi More Debat

In compliance with the JTI standards

More: SWI swissinfo certified by the Journalism Trust Initiative

You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!

If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at ... .

MENAFN17062024000210011054ID1108342442