Note From Taiwan: The Players On The Eve Of Destruction

But the Ukraine war was different - Russia wasn't simply recklessly intervening in a neighboring country but attempting to swallow it entirely. The age when great powers competed only by proxy and by temporary interventions was over, and the age of conquering empires had returned. The Russians themselves have said this openly , and the Chinese realized it as well :

If you think about this idea from first principles, its fundamental insanity becomes apparent. Spend a few days in Taiwan, and tell me honestly if there is anything wrong with it - some terrible injustice that needs to be corrected with saturation missile strikes and invasion fleets.

You cannot. The people here are happy and wealthy and free. The cities are safe and clean. There is no festering racial or religious or cultural conflict, no seething political anger among the citizenry. Everyone here simply wants things to remain the same .

And yet there is a good chance they may not be granted that wish. High explosives may soon rain down on their homes and their families, and an army of stormtroopers may march in and take all of their freedoms from them.

And if this happens, it will be because of the will of men far away - an emperor on a throne, generals hungry for glory, bored malcontents behind a computer screen. If these peaceful, unthreatening people suffer and die, it will be because those distant men decreed that they should.

Why would you do this? Why would anyone want to launch wars of conquest? The world has progressed beyond the economic need for warfare - China will not become richer by seizing the fabs of TSMC or the tea plantations of Sun Moon Lake. The mostly stable world created in the aftermath of the Cold War was good not just for Taiwan, but for China as well. Why topple it all chasing a dream of empire?

The only possible answer here is that the world is created anew each generation. We still call China by the same name, we still draw it the same on a map, but essentially all of the people who remember the Long March, or the Rape of Nanking, or the Battle of Shanghai are dead and gone.

The hard-won wisdom that they received as inadequate compensation for suffering through those terrible events has vanished into the entropy of history, and their descendants have only war movies and books and half-remembered tales to give them thin, shadowed glimpses.

And so the new people who are now“China” are able to believe that war is a glorious thing instead of a tragic one. They are able to imagine that by coloring Taiwan a different color on a map, their army will redress the wrongs of history, bring dignity to their race, spread the bounties of communist rule, fulfill a nation's manifest destiny, or whatever other nonsense they tell themselves. They imagine themselves either insulated from the consequences of that violence or purified and ennobled by their efforts to support it.

They do not understand, in the words of William T Sherman, that“war is destruction and nothing else.” Nor do they think very hard about the future of the world their short, glorious conquest of Taiwan would inaugurate - the nuclear proliferation, the arms races, the follow-on wars.

The German and Russian citizens who cheered their armies and threw flowers as they marched to the front in 1914 could not imagine Stalingrad and Dresden 30 years later. We have seen this movie before.

From the supporters of empire, the rejoinder is always: Why resist? Why not simply invite in the armies of the empire next door, take the knee, and submit to being the emperor's subjects? Wouldn't a world united under the iron grip of a single dictator be a peaceful one?

Was this not why the Ming Dynasty knew two centuries of peace, and the Qing? Perhaps Xi Jinping's China and Putin's Russia are not the most free or pleasant places to live in the world, but isn't that life preferable to searching for your mother's corpse in the rubble of your family home?

Isn't the true tragedy that humans are too obstreperous and obstinate to simply submit to the bringers of order? Won't we all feel better when the messy business of conquering is over and we can enjoy the order that the conquerors bring? Isn't every peaceful, rich, happy nation on Earth
built on the bones of the defeated
- including
Taiwan itself ?

The answer to this challenge is neither easy nor obvious. But looking at what the new empires of the 21st century have wrought, I think it's clear that the type of regimes who would shatter the peaceful world of the late 20th are not the type who would follow up a quick conquest with years of peace.

The conquered areas of Ukraine are living nightmares , where the men are press-ganged into wars for further conquest, suspected dissidents are tortured without due process, women are subject to arbitrary rape, and families are plundered at will. Russia itself is marginally less repressive than its conquered territories, but there is a reason why so many people want to leave .

Nor is there any indication that this new Russian empire will forsake its orientation around war and conquest anytime soon - after all, after Ukraine there are still the Baltics, and Moldova, and Poland , and even Germany . Putin was not satisfied with Georgia in 2008, nor with Crimea and the Donbas in 2014, and neither he nor his successors is likely to be satisfied with Ukraine if it falls.

The modern Russian state is oriented around war - the machine will grind on, and forced conscription in each conquered area will be used to fuel the cannon fodder for the next conquest, as it was in the days of the tsars and the khans.

What about China? On one hand, unlike Russia, it's a productive, manufacturing-oriented state - a repressive place in many ways, but unless you're
a Uighur
in Xinjiang, not exactly a nightmare. Hong Kongers have experienced
a steady loss
of
political and cultural freedoms
since the city's peaceful resistance was crushed a few years ago, but people are not yet being sent to the camps or slaughtered in the street.

And yet China is becoming a more repressive place over time, as its power grows. The government is building hundreds of new detention facilities all across the country for the emperor's political opponents. The civil society that began to flourish in previous decades has been increasingly ground into nothingness .

The bargain in which the state provides economic growth in exchange for rights and freedoms has broken down, and Chinese people are now asked to accept the authoritarianism without the growth.

Discontent may not yet be so apparent that tourists are inundated with expressions of rage, but signs of dissatisfaction are on the rise , and those who can get money out of the country are generally doing it .

If you bend the knee to Earth's new empires, you are essentially making a bet that these trends will reverse themselves - that the repression is a temporary expedient, a necessary transitory phase while the empires establish order, after which things will get better for your grandchildren.

There are many times and places in history when such a bet would have actually paid off. But the Ukrainians who are resisting Russian conquest have decided that given their history with previous incarnations of that empire, it's a bad bet this time.

Whether Taiwan will resist or capitulate in the face of overwhelming force remains to be seen, but the other nations in Asia - Japan, Vietnam, Korea, etc - have a long history of refusing to incorporate themselves into Chinese empires.

Sign up for one of our free newsletters

• The Daily Report Start your day right with Asia Times' top stories
• AT Weekly Report A weekly roundup of Asia Times' most-read stories

Until now, the independence of those countries has been guaranteed by the intercession of a more distant great power - the United States. But that once-mighty nation is increasingly not in a condition to resist the Chinese empire - or even the far weaker Russian one.

A decade of roiling social unrest and three decades of increasingly intractable political division have turned the country inward; Americans are too afraid of the enemy next door to worry about a friend six thousand miles away.

And decades of pro-stasis policies - a toxic bargain between progressives who wanted to shackle industry and conservatives who wanted to shackle government - have paralyzed the country's ability to respond to new challenges and threats.

While China leaps from strength to strength in robotics , drones , shipbuilding , AI , and a thousand other products, America's progressive intelligentsia view new technologies and the companies that build them with suspicion and distrust . While China dominates global manufacturing , America forces companies to hold a block party before building an EV charger.

And whether the US is even committed to global freedom in the abstract is now an open question. The fabulously wealthy businessmen who have the greatest influence in the new administration openly mock the courageous Ukrainians who stayed and risked death to defend their homes and families from the rape of Russia's invasion - even though if war ever came to their own doorstep, they would be the first to flee, clutching their Bitcoin to their chests like sacks of gold.

An aging Donald Trump indulges in idle fantasies of staging his own territorial conquests in the Western Hemisphere, LARPing the new fad for imperialism even as his peers practice the real thing overseas.

America, like every other nation, has been created anew as the generations turned. This is not the America of Franklin D Roosevelt, or even the America of Ronald Reagan. My grandparents are dead. Their hard-earned warnings are abstract words fading into memory, and I wonder if the world they won will outlast them by much.

And so across the sea, the old storm clouds gather again. In the seas around Taiwan, an armada assembles . Across the strait, the emperor orders a million kamikaze drones , hundreds of nuclear weapons , a forest of ballistic missiles , and a vast new navy . In Taipei, the sun is out, and people sip their tea, and eat their beef noodle soup, and and try not to think too hard about whether this will be the year the old world finally gives way to new.

This article was first published on Noah Smith's Noahpinion Substack and is republished with kind permission. Become a Noahopinion subscriber here.

Sign up here to comment on Asia Times stories Or Sign in to an existing accoun

Thank you for registering!

An account was already registered with this email. Please check your inbox for an authentication link.

• Click to share on X (Opens in new window)
• Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
• Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
• Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
• Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
• Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
• Click to print (Opens in new window)