Pakistan Elections May Not Lead To A Meaningful Alternative

The Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) has refused to grant PTI its designated electoral symbol, the cricket bat. Consequently, a majority of its candidates are now compelled to participate in the election as Independents. Imran Khan, the leader of PTI, has been disqualified from participating in the elections. He is barred from holding any public office for the next decade.

Once a figure endorsed by the Pakistan Army, Imran Khan has transformed into the military's primary adversary. The discord originated with the military's appointment of Lieutenant-General Nadeem Ahmed Anjum as the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) chief against Khan's wishes, along with Khan's visit to Russia.

The latter showed Pakistan's aggressive neutral position at the beginning of the Ukraine-Russia war, which could have upset the US. Later, Khan's supporters vandalized one of the generals' residences after his arrest. The generals aimed to remove him, and now they have accomplished their objective.

However, Pakistan's political class and its military have historically experienced a complex relationship of collaboration and conflict. Throughout Pakistan's history, military interventions have been a recurring theme.

A pivotal instance occurred in 1958 when president Iskander Mirza declared martial law, nullified the constitution, and shuttered the national and provincial assemblies. General Mohammad Ayub Khan assumed control, marking the onset of military rule. Since then, Pakistan has experienced multiple military interventions.

According to the Pakistan Army Act, the armed forces' duties include protecting the nation from outside threats and aggression as well as supporting civil authority when necessary. On policy topics, however, differences between the civilian and military governments have frequently occurred. The military has taken power on several occasions by using opposition parties as tools.

Pakistan consistently spends a significant portion of its budget on defense, with the 2022 allocation reaching 17.9% of GDP . This is a significant figure, particularly for a country where the per capita income in 2022 stood at US$1,590, equivalent to about $4.35 per day .

In Pakistan, the current economic landscape is characterized by a stark reality as inflation has surged to unprecedented levels, exceeding 30% and reaching a 50-year high in 2023 . Last month, it stood at 28.3% .

This economic turbulence is further underscored by the country's position in the region, where its GDP, per capita income, and GDP growth are among the lowest. Persistent challenges in terms of high unemployment and inflation rates contribute to the overall economic strain.

According to the United Nations Development Program's Human Development Index, Pakistan is positioned at 161st out of 191 countries , indicating low achievements in crucial areas such as health, knowledge, and living standards. This places Pakistan among the 31 countries globally with the lowest human-development levels. The poverty rate in Pakistan was 39.4% in 2022.

The situation was aggravated by the devastating floods experienced in the country in 2022. The floods not only caused widespread damage to agricultural land and critical infrastructure but also had a cascading effect on the overall economy. The aftermath of the floods triggered a surge in inflation, particularly impacting food prices, and increasing the economic hardships faced by the people.

The escalating cost of living, rising unemployment, and the specter of stagflation – all intertwined with the limitations of growth – are symptoms of a larger crisis rooted in neoliberal capitalism.

Sign up for one of our free newsletters

• The Daily Report Start your day right with Asia Times' top stories
• AT Weekly Report A weekly roundup of Asia Times' most-read stories

This predicament is not exclusive to a particular regime; rather, it stems from the overarching influence of a neoliberal framework that hinders effective crisis management by successive governments. The structural issues at play persist regardless of shifts between political parties or military dictatorships.

The challenges at hand are embedded in Pakistan's position within the global political economy of neoliberal capitalism. Pakistan finds itself struggling to compete, leading to a significant socio-economic toll.

Pakistan is increasingly becoming the working-class back yard of international capital, with its ability to produce a workforce destined to work abroad, making products that the domestic working class can barely afford. With an annual exodus of more than 800,000 pepple seeking employment abroad, a new underclass is emerging within the nation, composed of individuals keen on obtaining employment that the country is not able to offer.

A significant aspect contributing to Pakistan's economic challenges is its heavy reliance on foreign loans, often acquired at high interest rates. The country currently operates on these loans, facing the formidable task of repaying a substantial debt amounting to $80 billion within the next three years .

The ongoing crisis in Pakistan cannot be resolved simply by swapping one political party for another. It is intricately tied to deep-seated issues of inequality, power concentrated in the hands of a few, and a lack of commitment from leaders to present a viable alternative.

The ability of a new political entity to overcome these challenges remains uncertain. Nevertheless, these elections carry significant weight as the population is enduring hardship, skepticism toward the electoral process is widespread, and the nation appears to be spiraling into an uncertain future with no clear path of recovery.

Already have an account? Sign i Sign up here to comment on Asia Times stories OR

Thank you for registering!

An account was already registered with this email. Please check your inbox for an authentication link.