(MENAFN- Asia Times) The October 11 arrest of Ashley J Tellis, a towering figure in US-India relations, by the US Department of Justice has reverberated with shock and disbelief in diplomatic and strategic circles in Washington and New Delhi.

The DOJ charged Tellis, a 64-year-old India-born strategist, with illegally possessing thousands of classified national security documents and holding unauthorized meetings with Chinese officials, allegations that have stunned observers. If found guilty, he faces up to a decade in prison.

Tellis's arrest is not just a personal criminal scandal; it is a seismic jolt to the US-India strategic partnership, exposing the fragility of a relationship on which India has staked its geopolitical ambitions.

His downfall is a stark warning: India's policy of placing all its strategic eggs in America's basket was a reckless bet, now teetering on the brink of collapse. Long hailed as the architect of decades-long US-India ties, Tellis was the linchpin in elevating India's status as a key American ally and strategic partner in the Indo-Pacific.

Educated at St. Xavier's College in Mumbai and the University of Chicago, where he earned a PhD in political science, Tellis arrived in India in 2000 as a special assistant to US Ambassador Robert Blackwill. His intellectual rigor and diplomatic acumen shaped transformative initiatives, most notably the 2008 US-India Civil Nuclear Agreement.

This landmark deal lifted sanctions imposed after India's 1998 Pokhran nuclear tests, granting New Delhi access to nuclear energy technology and entry into global nuclear regulatory bodies. The charges against him now overshadow Tellis's personal and professional achievements, a loss that is already deeply felt in diplomatic and strategic circles.

Tellis's advocacy provided the intellectual scaffolding that fostered trust, unlocked US defense technology transfers and deepened bilateral ties, positioning India as a counterweight to China.

His influence, which spanned multiple US administrations, was strategically crucial. During George W Bush's presidency (2001-2009), Tellis served on the National Security Council and in the Southwest Asia Strategic Planning Office, helping to shape policies that prioritized India's strategic rise.

Under Barack Obama (2009-2017), he championed defense industrial cooperation, enabling India to bolster its military capabilities through advanced technology transfers.

His efforts helped secure India's designation as a“major defense partner” under Obama's“Pivot to Asia” policy, accelerating bilateral trade and defense partnerships in the process.

During Donald Trump's first term (2017-2021), Tellis played a key role in shaping the“Indo-Pacific strategy”, which Rex Tillerson, Trump's first secretary of state, rebranded from Obama's earlier pivot.

Latest stories

Philippines eyes Korean ship-killer missiles to point at China

Gaza peace? Maybe, maybe not

Meta's Vietnam playbook: comply, delete and keep quiet

India gained access to sensitive US intelligence and cutting-edge technologies once reserved for formal allies. India signed four foundational agreements with the US, which formally designated India as a key US ally and strategic partner.

Rumours even circulated in 2017 that Tellis was a contender for US ambassador to India, underscoring his influence. He leveraged his close rapport with both Indian and US leaders to secure defense deals and navigate tensions, including those arising from the Indo-Pakistan conflicts.

Under the Joe Biden administration (2021-2025), Tellis continued to shape policy by advocating stronger Quad cooperation and facilitating the transfer of advanced fighter jet engine technology to India.

Trellis's 2022 book, “Grasping Greatness”, launched by Indian External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar, highlighted his deep ties with New Delhi's political elite, from former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to Narendra Modi.

His 2025 Foreign Affairs article, “India's Great-Power Delusions,” argued that India must remain under the US security umbrella to counter China's rise-a position he had long championed. Yet, Tellis's arrest under Trump's second administration, which began in January 2025, marks a dramatic rupture.

The charges-stemming from the discovery of classified documents at his Virginia home and alleged discussions with Chinese officials on sensitive topics like Iran-China and US-Pakistan relations-cast a long shadow over his legacy.

An FBI affidavit alleges that Tellis printed classified documents on US fighter jets from a secure Pentagon computer on September 12, 2025. This breach, coupled with the hardline stance of Trump's Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, who has vowed zero tolerance for mishandling classified information, has imbued the arrest with political overtones.

The timing is no coincidence. Trump's“Make America Great Again” agenda has taken a more confrontational turn toward India, with threats of high tariffs and demands for lopsided trade deals to address the US trade deficit. India currently faces a 50% tariff, much higher than regional counterparts hit with Trump's“reciprocal tariffs.”

Tellis's detention signals a broader shift in US policy. Washington no longer views India as an indispensable ally but as a transactional partner of diminishing value. For years, Tellis has argued that India's strategic alignment with the US is essential to counter China.

His arrest suggests that the US is now reevaluating that calculus. This reevaluation could lead to a significant shift in US-India relations, potentially altering the dynamics of the Quad and the Indo-Pacific strategy.

The Asia Group has severed ties with him, think tanks have scrubbed his name from their websites, and his credibility lies in ruins. India's Ministry of External Affairs has remained silent, but the implications for bilateral ties, the Quad and the Indo-Pacific strategy are profound.

The Trump administration's claim that India remains a strategic partner now rings hollow in the wake of the incident. India's strategic miscalculation is now painfully clear. For decades, New Delhi leaned heavily on the US, betting that alignment would yield economic and military dividends while deterring China.

The US anticipated India would become a $10 trillion economy by 2025, a major buyer of American weapons systems and a linchpin against Beijing. But India's economic growth has fallen short, its defense acquisitions have diversified to include Russian and French systems, and its commitment to“strategic autonomy”-rooted in its non-aligned tradition-has frustrated Washington's expectations.

Strategic autonomy, a key principle of India's foreign policy, refers to its ability to make independent decisions and pursue its national interests without being overly dependent on any single power. This doctrine has led India to diversify defense acquisitions and strike a balanced approach in international relations.

Tellis's arrest exposes the limits of US-India partnership and the risks of overreliance on a single power. This episode underscores the dangers of India's all-in bet on America – one that sidelined other strategic options and left New Delhi vulnerable to Washington's shifting priorities.

Trump's first term was marked by a personal rapport with Modi, facilitated by Tellis's diplomacy. But the second term has revealed that US national interest trumps friendship. The US has long viewed India as a counterbalance to China, but its patience is wearing thin as India falls short of expectations.

Sign up for one of our free newsletters

• The Daily Report Start your day right with Asia Times' top stories
• AT Weekly Report A weekly roundup of Asia Times' most-read stories

Tellis's arrest is less about his alleged crimes and more about Washington signaling a downgrade in India's strategic relevance. So what lies ahead for US-India relations? Without Tellis's personal and institutional influence, the relationship risks drifting into mediocrity.

The Quad, once a cornerstone of America's Indo-Pacific strategy, could falter as India reassesses its role in the region. Trump's tariff threats and cooling ties with China could have positioned India as a beneficiary, but Tellis's fall suggests the US is unwilling to extend such opportunities.

India must now confront an uncomfortable truth: America is not at all a reliable partner. US strategic pivots are driven by domestic politics and self-interest, not enduring alliances and partnerships. This is a pivotal moment for India to reassess its decades-long approach. Instead of doubling down on a faltering US partnership, New Delhi should diversify its strategic portfolio.

It should strengthen ties with Japan, Australia and ASEAN nations, deepen economic integration with RCEP and Europe, playing a pivotal role in the BRICS+ nations to de-dollarize and further strengthen relations with Russia while pursuing economically beneficial cooperation with China.

India should also invest in indigenous defense capabilities-accelerating the development of domestic fighter jets and naval assets-and pursue domestic economic policies to boost job growth.

India must move beyond the illusion of an unshakable US alliance and recognize that overdependence on any single partner invites vulnerability. The US-India strategic partnership, painstakingly built over decades, is not dead but it is fraying. Tellis's detention marks a symbolic rupture, exposing the costs and risks of India's gamble on America.

As New Delhi navigates this uncertain terrain, it must learn a critical lesson: in geopolitics, no partner is indispensable. Tellis's arrest is not just the end of an era–it is a clarion call for India to forge a more resilient, self-reliant path in a multipolar world.

Follow Bhim Bhurtel is on X at @BhimBhurtel

Sign up here to comment on Asia Times stories Or Sign in to an existing accoun

Thank you for registering!

An account was already registered with this email. Please check your inbox for an authentication link.

• Click to share on X (Opens in new window)
• Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedI
• Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Faceboo
• Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsAp
• Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddi
• Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Emai
• Click to print (Opens in new window) Prin

MENAFN16102025000159011032ID1110205218