Syngenta Loses Appeal Against Swiss Ban On Chlorothalonil Fungicides

The FOAG decision was issued with effect on January 1, 2020, which meant that stocks of products containing this substance could no longer be sold.

In 2020, the agrochemical group Syngenta, which produces fungicides containing chlorothalonil, filed an appeal before the Federal Administrative Court. According to the manufacturer of plant protection products, the metabolites of the substance found in groundwater would not be harmful to humans.

The Court noted the significant risk of the substance for amphibians and for fish. This observation alone is sufficient to confirm the legality of the ban.

In addition to this danger for the environment, the Court also noted that metabolites exceeding the threshold of 0.1 micrograms per liter of groundwater have been detected.

Even if these cases were identified in isolation, the presence of metabolites in the samples implies that the limit values were not respected. The ban is thus also relevant from the point of view of the protection of groundwater and drinking water.

This content was published on May 2, 2024 Getting farmers to switch to organic farming is hard. Could giving up pesticides while still being able to use synthetic fertilisers help them to make the transition?

Environmental lobby group WWF participated in the proceedings by arguing that the substance in question posed a risk to aquatic fauna, in particular amphibians, and that its presence in groundwater also constituted a risk to public health.

The European Union banned chlorothalonil as early as April 2019, pointing out the risk for fish and amphibians represented by groundwater and drinking water pollution.

Syngenta can still appeal to the Federal Court, the highest court in the country.

Adapted from French by AI/ac