Bara Bazaar's Anti-Encroachment Drive: A Tale Of Struggles And Unanswered Questions

(MENAFN- Tribal News Network) For the past few days-since the anti-encroachment operation began in Bara Bazaar-I have found myself unable to stop thinking about a group often overlooked: our hardworking pushcart vendors. A verse from Nasir Kazmi comes to mind:
“On the walls of our house, Nasir,
Sadness sleeps with its hair untied.”

This sadness, it seems, has become a shared experience across Pakistan, especially in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and the merged districts. While the reasons may differ, the outcomes are disturbingly similar: despair and struggle. For some, it's the loss of loved ones to extremism; for others, it's the unending thirst for a secure livelihood. One relentless beast looms large, exacerbating all these woes-poverty.

Also Read: Flood-Hit Farmers in Charsadda Struggle as Faulty Maize Seeds Lead to Crop Failure

Poverty forces compromise, breeds crime, and corners people with impossible choices. In Bara Bazaar, the so-called anti-encroachment operation has become a grim example of this struggle, particularly for pushcart vendors who already endure grueling lives. From morning till night, they work under the open sky, braving heat and cold, earning just enough to support their families.

The Operation: Promises and Reality

The first phase of the operation-targeting pushcart vendors-was swift. Authorities claimed it was the beginning of a broader initiative that would eventually address illegal taxi and van stands. Promises were made to provide vendors with alternative spaces to operate. However, as weeks passed, the operation seemed to stall, with no progress in subsequent phases.

President of the Bara Traders Association, Syed Ayaz Wazir, criticized the authorities, stating:
“Instead of clearing all encroachments, the administration only removed helpless pushcart vendors. Taxi and other vehicle stands remain untouched. If the situation doesn't improve in two days, we will join the vendors to reclaim their old spots.”

According to Wazir, the operation has directly affected around 600 pushcart vendors, leaving their families-potentially thousands of individuals-struggling to make ends meet. With children, the elderly, and the sick depending on these incomes, the repercussions are vast.

A Systemic Problem

Pushcart vendors are not the only ones caught in this cycle. Across Pakistan, roadside stalls and encroachments have become an informal norm, with shopkeepers, residents, and even customers complicit in sustaining this system. Yet, when operations like these take place, it is the weakest-those with the least resources-who bear the brunt.

In the past, similar drives in areas like Firdous and Hashtnagri have unfolded in predictable patterns. Pushcarts are seized, goods are confiscated, and vendors are left scrambling to pay fines to retrieve their livelihoods. Fresh produce and goods often get damaged in the chaos, leading to further losses. While officials retreat to their comfortable offices, the pushcart vendors eventually return to the streets, perpetuating an unending cycle.

A Call for Fairness

Laws should apply equally to everyone. Targeting only the vulnerable is both unjust and counterproductive. The district administration and municipal corporations must take responsibility for providing designated spaces-such as vacant plots-for pushcart vendors. This would keep streets clear while ensuring vendors can continue earning their livelihoods.

In a country where millions depend on pushcarts for survival, outright bans only worsen unemployment and poverty. Instead, a balanced approach is needed-one that recognizes the rights of these vendors and addresses urban management challenges with compassion and foresight.

Bara Bazaar's vendors are not just statistics. They are individuals with dreams and struggles, caught in a system that needs reform, not just enforcement. The question remains: will the authorities rise to this challenge, or will the cycle of despair continue?

MENAFN27012025000189011041ID1109134719