Former Swiss Green Party Judge: 'ECHR Judgement Not Tenable'

(MENAFN- Swissinfo) Former Green Party federal judge Brigitte Pfiffner has described the climate judgement of the European Court of Human Rights as "legally untenable". The court is making policy instead of interpreting the convention on Human Rights, said Pfiffner.

This content was published on May 19, 2024 - 12:50 3 minutes Keystone-SDA

In the case of the climate seniors, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) barely addressed the central questions in the grounds for the judgement, said Pfiffner in an interview with the SonntagsZeitung newspaper published on Sunday. The Zurich native was a judge at the Federal Supreme Court for around ten years.

One of the questions is why an association is entitled to lodge a complaint and which human right has been violated by the Climate Seniors Association.“This is dealt with in just eleven lines in the 138-page judgement,” she said. The reasoning was“because the matter is important”, the former federal judge said.

+Landmark ruling: Switzerland's climate policy violates human rights

There was also no convincing answer to the question of the extent to which the association's“right to respect for private and family life” was restricted due to Swiss climate policy.“For logical reasons, there can't be any: The right to respect for private and family life can only accrue to a natural person,” said Pfiffner.

Declining reputation

“With such politically coloured judgements, the court undermines its credibility,” she said. In many countries, the Court's reputation is already in decline. In Germany, Austria and England, there are discussions as to whether ECHR judgements should still be considered binding or merely recommendations.

+'Absurd' European climate ruling could harm democracy, say Swiss press

At the beginning of April, the Court accepted a complaint from the Climate Seniors Association and found a violation of the Convention on Human Rights. According to the court, Switzerland had failed to fulfil its duties with regard to climate protection. Swiss politicians reacted very differently to the decision. The red-green party and environmental organisations welcomed the judgement. The conservative side said it was dangerous for the courts to play politics.

Adapted from German by DeepL/amva

This news story has been written and carefully fact-checked by an external editorial team. At SWI swissinfo we select the most relevant news for an international audience and use automatic translation tools such as DeepL to translate it into English. Providing you with automatically translated news gives us the time to write more in-depth articles.

If you want to know more about how we work, have a look here , and if you have feedback on this news story please write to ... .

External Content Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again. Almost finished... We need to confirm your email address. To complete the subscription process, please click the link in the email we just sent you. Daily news

Get the most important news from Switzerland in your inbox.

Daily

Email

The SBC Privacy Policy provides additional information on how your data is processed.

I consent to the use of my data for the SWI swissinfo newsletter.

News More Fatal wingsuit jump accident in canton Ticino

This content was published on May 19, 2024 A 36-year-old man from Ticino lost his life on Saturday in Val Malvaglia, in the north of canton Ticino, during a wingsuit jump from a plane.

Read more: Fatal wingsuit jump accident in canton Ticino More Swiss Evangelical Reformed Church numbers dropping in French-speaking Switzerland

This content was published on May 19, 2024 As in German-speaking Switzerland, the number of members of the Reformed Church in French-speaking Switzerland is also declining.

Read more: Swiss Evangelical Reformed Church numbers dropping in French-speaking Switzerland More Swiss hotel industry reflects on a successful winter season

This content was published on May 19, 2024 Nearly half of the accommodations reported an increase in turnover compared to the previous year.

Read more: Swiss hotel industry reflects on a successful winter season More Gotthard traffic queue hits 20km during holiday weekend

This content was published on May 18, 2024 The traffic jam at the Gotthard north portal reached a length of 20 kilometres on the motorway between canton Nidwalden and canton Uri.

Read more: Gotthard traffic queue hits 20km during holiday weekend More Swiss Interior Minister visits Cannes Film Festival

This content was published on May 18, 2024 Swiss Interior Minister left the Cannes Film Festival on Saturday after three days of intensive dialogue, meetings and film screenings.

Read more: Swiss Interior Minister visits Cannes Film Festival More Swiss theatre director breaks with tradition at Vienna's Rathausplatz

This content was published on May 18, 2024 With the proclamation of the "Free Republic of Vienna", the start of the festival on Friday evening was unusually political.

Read more: Swiss theatre director breaks with tradition at Vienna's Rathausplatz More Swiss parliament committee proposes tripling taxes for foreign students

This content was published on May 18, 2024 New students at the Federal Institute of Technology Lausanne (EPFL) from abroad will have to pay three times more taxes.

Read more: Swiss parliament committee proposes tripling taxes for foreign students More Putin: Swiss peace summit aimed at 'pressuring' Russia

This content was published on May 17, 2024 Russian president Vladimir Putin has again denounced the upcoming Ukraine peace summit in Switzerland.

Read more: Putin: Swiss peace summit aimed at 'pressuring' Russia More Nearly half of Swiss bee species on endangered 'red list'

This content was published on May 17, 2024 While many species suffer, others were found to be newly migrating to Switzerland as a result of climate change.

Read more: Nearly half of Swiss bee species on endangered 'red list' More Swiss foreign minister backs Berset at Council of Europe

This content was published on May 17, 2024 Cassis described Berset as the "ideal candidate" to help the Council realise its aim of ensuring security and peace in Europe.

Read more: Swiss foreign minister backs Berset at Council of Europe

In compliance with the JTI standards

More: SWI swissinfo certified by the Journalism Trust Initiative

You can find an overview of ongoing debates with our journalists here . Please join us!

If you want to start a conversation about a topic raised in this article or want to report factual errors, email us at ... .

Read more More Landmark ruling: Switzerland's climate policy violates human rights

This content was published on Apr 9, 2024 The European Court of Human Rights says the Swiss authorities are responsible for not implementing efficient climate change policies and for violating the right to life of a group of elderly women.

Read more: Landmark ruling: Switzerland's climate policy violates human rights

MENAFN19052024000210011054ID1108231811