AI Must Empower, Not Replace, Mediators: ICA-RICS Symposium Calls for Ethical Guardrails
(MENAFN- MENAFNEditorial) New Delhi, 21 November 2026: Senior legal practitioners, government policymakers, and international regulatory leaders on Saturday stressed that while artificial intelligence is rapidly transforming commercial dispute preparation, human judgement, confidentiality, and professional accountability cannot be delegated to an algorithm.
Addressing the joint conclave on organised by the Indian Council of Arbitration (ICA) and the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) at Federation House in New Delhi, speakers underlined that’India’s evolving mediation ecosystem must be anchored in institutional credibility and rigorous ethical saf uards.
Marking a key development at the conclave, Mr. Nigel Clarke, Independent Chair, Standards and Regulation Board, RICS, announced that RICS is developing new practice guidance on the use of AI in dispute resolution, with a draft set to be published for public consultation in early 2027. Buildi’g on RICS’s Professional Standard on the Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence in Surveying Practice introduced in March 2026, the upcoming guidance will address both the opportunities and risks of AI in dispute e“olution. “Institutional trust cannot be established by rules alone. It must be reinforced through professional standards, ethical conduct, and consiste”t practice,” Mr. Clarke said, noting that RICS is celebrating the 50th anniversary of its Dispute Resolution Service“(DRS) this year. “AI can assist professional analysis and decision-making, but it cannot replace human judgement or professional” countability.” Mr. Clarke also highlighted the RICS Women in Dispute Resolution Scholarship for India, which offers a funded place on the 18-month RICS Diploma in International Arbitration for women across legal, construction, engineering, project management, and quantity surveying disciplines. Applications for the scholarship remain open until 11 December 2026.
Delivering the opening address, Mr. Arun Chawla, Director General, ICA, emphasised that mediation has evolved into an instrument of commercial continuity and economic efficiency-part’cularly vital for India’s ambitious infrastructure and construction sectors. While acknowledging legislative milestones such as the Mediation Act, 2023 and the establishment of the Mediation Council of India, he noted that legislation alone cannot b ld a mediation culture.
“Our objective is not to replace the mediator with artificial intelligence; it should be to empower the mediator with artificial intelligence,” Mr. Chawla said. “Technology must support professional judgement, not substitute it. If institutions provide trust, professionals uphold standards, and technology delivers responsible innovation, mediation can become a cornerstone of commercial confidence, investment security, and sustainable economic growth."
Framing the transition from principles to practice, Mr. Chris Alder, Senior Executive Officer, Standards and Regulation, RICS, noted that India has a unique opportunity under the Mediation Act to embed responsible technology use into its modern mediation ecosystem from the outset. ““The real challenge is not simply how do we make mediation more efficient, it is how do we use technology to make mediation more effective without making it less trustw”rthy,” Mr. Alder said, addi“g that “accountability cannot and must not simply be delegated to an ” orithm.”
The conclave featured a panel “iscussion on “The Role of AI in Mediation - Practical Use, Risk and Professional Responsibility,” moderated by Mr. Alder, bringing together Mr. Avnit Singh Arora (Director (Arbitration and Conciliation), Department of Legal Affairs, Ministry of Law and Justice, GoI), Ms Priya Hingorani (Senior Advocate, Supreme Court of India, and ICA Governing Body Member), and Dr. John Fletcher (Executive Director, Dispute Resolution Service, RICS). Distinguishing mediation as a collaborative commercial negotiation rather than adversarial litigation or arbitration, panellists noted that while AI can assist in pre-mediation preparation, litigation risk analysis, and administrativ“ efficiency as a ⦣8221;junior assistant,” it cannot replace human trust or judgement. They cautioned that where power imbalances exist between parties, persuasive yet inaccurate AI-generated analyses risk misleading participants, skewing negotiations, and triggering flawed settlements that push disputes back into courts or arbitration. To safeguard the process, speakers emphasised data-privacy-compliant platforms, human cross-checking, counsel responsibility, and experienced, sector-specialist mediators. Together, the deliberations ’eflected ICA and RICS’s shared commitment to strengthening credible, standards-driven mediation and commercial dispute resolution aligned with global benchmarks.
Addressing the joint conclave on organised by the Indian Council of Arbitration (ICA) and the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) at Federation House in New Delhi, speakers underlined that’India’s evolving mediation ecosystem must be anchored in institutional credibility and rigorous ethical saf uards.
Marking a key development at the conclave, Mr. Nigel Clarke, Independent Chair, Standards and Regulation Board, RICS, announced that RICS is developing new practice guidance on the use of AI in dispute resolution, with a draft set to be published for public consultation in early 2027. Buildi’g on RICS’s Professional Standard on the Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence in Surveying Practice introduced in March 2026, the upcoming guidance will address both the opportunities and risks of AI in dispute e“olution. “Institutional trust cannot be established by rules alone. It must be reinforced through professional standards, ethical conduct, and consiste”t practice,” Mr. Clarke said, noting that RICS is celebrating the 50th anniversary of its Dispute Resolution Service“(DRS) this year. “AI can assist professional analysis and decision-making, but it cannot replace human judgement or professional” countability.” Mr. Clarke also highlighted the RICS Women in Dispute Resolution Scholarship for India, which offers a funded place on the 18-month RICS Diploma in International Arbitration for women across legal, construction, engineering, project management, and quantity surveying disciplines. Applications for the scholarship remain open until 11 December 2026.
Delivering the opening address, Mr. Arun Chawla, Director General, ICA, emphasised that mediation has evolved into an instrument of commercial continuity and economic efficiency-part’cularly vital for India’s ambitious infrastructure and construction sectors. While acknowledging legislative milestones such as the Mediation Act, 2023 and the establishment of the Mediation Council of India, he noted that legislation alone cannot b ld a mediation culture.
“Our objective is not to replace the mediator with artificial intelligence; it should be to empower the mediator with artificial intelligence,” Mr. Chawla said. “Technology must support professional judgement, not substitute it. If institutions provide trust, professionals uphold standards, and technology delivers responsible innovation, mediation can become a cornerstone of commercial confidence, investment security, and sustainable economic growth."
Framing the transition from principles to practice, Mr. Chris Alder, Senior Executive Officer, Standards and Regulation, RICS, noted that India has a unique opportunity under the Mediation Act to embed responsible technology use into its modern mediation ecosystem from the outset. ““The real challenge is not simply how do we make mediation more efficient, it is how do we use technology to make mediation more effective without making it less trustw”rthy,” Mr. Alder said, addi“g that “accountability cannot and must not simply be delegated to an ” orithm.”
The conclave featured a panel “iscussion on “The Role of AI in Mediation - Practical Use, Risk and Professional Responsibility,” moderated by Mr. Alder, bringing together Mr. Avnit Singh Arora (Director (Arbitration and Conciliation), Department of Legal Affairs, Ministry of Law and Justice, GoI), Ms Priya Hingorani (Senior Advocate, Supreme Court of India, and ICA Governing Body Member), and Dr. John Fletcher (Executive Director, Dispute Resolution Service, RICS). Distinguishing mediation as a collaborative commercial negotiation rather than adversarial litigation or arbitration, panellists noted that while AI can assist in pre-mediation preparation, litigation risk analysis, and administrativ“ efficiency as a ⦣8221;junior assistant,” it cannot replace human trust or judgement. They cautioned that where power imbalances exist between parties, persuasive yet inaccurate AI-generated analyses risk misleading participants, skewing negotiations, and triggering flawed settlements that push disputes back into courts or arbitration. To safeguard the process, speakers emphasised data-privacy-compliant platforms, human cross-checking, counsel responsibility, and experienced, sector-specialist mediators. Together, the deliberations ’eflected ICA and RICS’s shared commitment to strengthening credible, standards-driven mediation and commercial dispute resolution aligned with global benchmarks.
Legal Disclaimer:
MENAFN provides the
information “as is” without warranty of any kind. We do not accept any
responsibility or liability for the accuracy, content, images, videos,
licenses, completeness, legality, or reliability of the information
contained in this article. If you have any complaints or copyright issues
related to this article, kindly contact the provider above.

Comments
No comment