Milan Ilic Photographer/Shutterstock
Milan Ilic Photographer/Shutterstock

Diplomacy, Humour And Avoidance What We Found When We Investigated Friendships Across Class Divides


Date:

Author: Sam Friedman
(MENAFN- The Conversation) Several years ago, the US economist Raj Chetty and his team at Harvard University analysed billions of ties on Facebook in a bid to learn more about social mobility. Their findings highlighted an important link between cross-class friendship and social mobility. Specifically, they found that people from low-income backgrounds who have more friends from wealthier backgrounds tend to have better chances of earning more as adults.

The paper was published in the journal Nature in 2022. Last year, a report from the Behavioural Insights Team came to the same conclusions in the UK. Both have since been seized upon by policymakers seeking to boost social mobility in the general population.

But we were puzzled. Not only did this work seem to rely on a speculative understanding of how friendships actually work, but the conclusions fly in the face of decades of sociological research. Specifically, that friendship rests on reciprocity between friends, not one-way transfers.

In our new paper, we investigated this tension via 42 in-depth interviews with people in cross-class friendships in the UK. We found that these friendships can indeed produce“social capital”. That is, more privileged friends often provide financial support or cultural guidance to less privileged friends navigating elite spaces. Yet our research also underlines the limitations of characterising cross-class friendship in this way.

In our interviews, when support tended to flow only one way, it generated feelings of inequality or indebtedness, and often sent friendships into a downward spiral. Take Tania (not her real name), a researcher who was white and from a lower-middle-class background. She met Florence at Durham University, where Tania was struggling with the“social side of things”.

In these alien environments, Florence, who was privately educated, acted as what Tania called her“pathfinder”. Tania watched how Florence worked a room. She wasn't comfortable doing the same on her own terms, so she mirrored how Florence“took up space”.

Yet Tania had mixed feelings about this. It had helped her navigate a career in the civil service – she became“posh Tania” at work – but she was troubled by the feeling that the friendship felt contingent on her assimilation. In other words, if she“dropped back down”, Florence might not stick around.

Class diplomacy

Against the arguments of the original study in Nature, the successful cross-class friendships we studied were not based on one-way transfers. Rather, they relied on a careful negotiation of class difference, which we term“class diplomacy”.

Diplomacy is a useful term, because it shows how managing class difference is an ongoing part of these friendships. It requires significant emotion work (although this burden is not necessarily felt equally) and demands certain social skills from both parties.

We identified three modes of class diplomacy: joking, avoiding and confronting. First, many friends used teasing and self-deprecation to voice and defuse class tensions. Humour was present across genders, but it was more overtly connected to class in male friendships. Typically, it played out in terms of mocking oneself or each other in class terms.

Peter, a banker from a white working-class family, explained the enduring role that“taking the piss” played in his friendship with Julian (“your typical private schoolboy jokes”). What was important, though, was that Julian would take this on the chin. In this way, joking – particularly jokes that punched upwards – recognised class difference but also registered how it affected their experiences in different ways.

The second way diplomacy played out was via the choice many had made to avoid discussing class. Avoidance allowed forms of connection to flourish – interviewees told us these would be stymied if they were to confront class.

But at the same time, interviewees were acutely aware of how class difference continually threatened the friendship. Both friends intricately navigated how and when to coordinate their mutual avoidance.

Many described pivoting to other sources of shared connection such as gender, race, sexuality or taste. This did not cancel out tensions – class“landmines” – yet focusing on commonality provided a kind of refuge.

Others chose to confront class difference head-on. These participants, disproportionately women, acknowledged the risks of this honesty, but said that, if accompanied by sensitivity, it could be productive.

Shanthi and Nadia agreed that their different backgrounds had largely been superseded by the“bonding effect” of being two women of colour growing up in a“very white” area. Yet the issue of money was an ongoing tension.

Nadia, whose upbringing had been marked by economic precarity, was uncomfortable with Shanthi continually offering to buy her things. Shanthi realised that even if her offers were coming from a“place of love”, they almost legitimised a power difference.

Class diplomacy paves the way for forms of exchange and reciprocity to flourish between friends. This is vital for friendships across class to persist. In the relationships we studied, this also had a mutually socialising effect that often led to a heightened sensitivity to class inequality.

Friends spoke of how they had been“shaped” by one another. For those from more advantaged backgrounds, this was often about confronting one's own class privilege and snobbery – of bringing out, as charity worker Marco noted,“behaviours in me that I'm a bit ashamed of and I'm hyper-aware of now”.

For less privileged friends, diplomacy helped them to understand someone they initially saw only through the lens of privilege, and subsequently be more empathetic, while maintaining their critical stance on class inequality.

These results provide a rejoinder to economists who, in a rush to find a magic bullet to social mobility, may have passed over the complexities of cross-class friendship. It's not just about the creation of these friendships, but their quality and longevity, and fostering the conditions where they can flourish.

This article was co-published with LSE Blogs at the London School of Economics


The Conversation

MENAFN19112026000199003603ID1111988820

Institution:Deakin University

The Conversation

Legal Disclaimer:
MENAFN provides the information “as is” without warranty of any kind. We do not accept any responsibility or liability for the accuracy, content, images, videos, licenses, completeness, legality, or reliability of the information contained in this article. If you have any complaints or copyright issues related to this article, kindly contact the provider above.



More Story

Search