IND Vs NZ, 1St Test: Shubman Gill Argues With Umpire Over Failed LBW Review Against Glenn Phillips (WATCH)
India captain Shubman Gill appeared to have expressed his frustration with the on-field umpire after a controversial DRS verdict denied Jasprit Bumrah a crucial breakthrough against New Zealand's Glenn Phillips on Day 1 of the ongoing first Test at Basin Reserve in Wellington on Thursday, November 19.
After opting to bowl first, India pacers ripped through New Zealand's batting line-up, reducing the hosts to 70/5 in 28.2 overs, with Jasprit Bumrah leading the charge with three early wickets of Tom Latham, Daryl Mitchell, and Tom Bundell, putting early pressure on the visitors' middle order.
However, New Zealand's batting has been revived through an unbeaten 173-run partnership for the sixth wicket between Henry Nicholls (113) and Glenn Phillips (86), as the hosts posted a total of 243/5 in 82 overs on Day 1 of the opening Test.
Also Read:Jasprit Bumrah Surpasses Srinath to Join Top 10 Test Wicket-Takers
Gill's Animated Argument With Umpire Over DRS Call
As India pacers made early inroads before New Zealand began to rebuild, Shubman Gill found himself at the centre of a heated on-field exchange with on-field umpire Richard Illingworth after a DRS call went against the visitors.
The incident took place in the 31st over of New Zealand's innings when Jasprit Bumrah bowled a delivery that nipped back sharply and struck Glenn Phillips on the back pad. India appealed for DRS, believing that the ball had hit Phillips' pad without making contact with the bat.
However, the giant screen showed a spike on the Snickometer as the ball passed close to the bat, indicating a possible inside edge. The third umpire, Paul Reiffel, upheld Illingworth's original not-out decision after the review suggested that Phillips had edged the ball onto his pad, leaving India without a successful review.
Then, Shubman Gill had an animated exchange with on-field umpire Richard Illingworth, questioning the decision and appearing unconvinced by the third umpire's verdict. He was visibly frustrated as he gestured towards the giant screen, insisting that there was a gap between the bat and ball.
The skipper isn't pleased!
A tense moment in the middle as Shubman Gill makes his case to the umpire!
Watch the HERO VIDA India Tour of New Zealand, 1st Test, LIVE NOW on Sony Sports Network TV channels & amp; Sony LIV.
#SonySportsNetwork #SonyLIV #NZvIND Sony Sports Network (@SonySportsNetwk) November 19, 2026
Despite Shubman Gill's argument, the on-field umpire Richard Illingworth stood by his original decision, and Glenn Phillips continued his innings. Gill eventually walked away by shaking his head, while the failed review left India with one fewer DRS opportunity.
Phillips survived the DRS call and went on to score an unbeaten 94 off 182 deliveries, including 13 boundaries.
'No Bat Involved': Fans Question Snickometer After Phillips Survives
India skipper Shubman Gill's animated reaction to the DRS verdict sparked widespread debate among cricket fans on social media, especially X (formerly Twitter), with many questioning the reliability of the Snickometer technology and insisting that Glenn Phillips should have been given out.
Taking to their X handles, many fans expressed disbelief over the third umpire's decision, arguing that there was no contact between the bat and ball and that Phillips should have been given out, while others questioned the Snickometer technology, with some calling the verdict a poor decision by the third umpire.
Another section of fans criticised the use of the technology, with some calling for it to be scrapped and arguing that the decision was incorrect despite the available replays. Several also praised Gill for questioning the verdict and standing by his team's appeal.
@SonySportsNetwk That was clear out, even without sonic i can make this out.. ridiculous sonic technology.. ultraedge or snicko is better
- Anurag Sinha (@anuragsinha1992) November 19, 2026
@SonySportsNetwk That was horrible. He's out for sure. Great delivery by Bumrah
- Sandeep (@sandeep_sep19) November 19, 2026
@SonySportsNetwk There is no bat involved worst decision made by an umpire
- Karthik Mecheneer (@jjkarthik12) November 19, 2026
@SonySportsNetwk This is plumb. What kind of mf technology is this Just pure bullshit.
- Satyanshu Tiwary (@saty89273) November 19, 2026
@SonySportsNetwk with naked eye we can tell there is no bat @ICC wha kind of stupid board you are
- Nandu (@devd_dhfmpro) November 19, 2026
@SonySportsNetwk That was plumb.
- Mr (@idoastrovastu) November 19, 2026
Glenn Philips was clear OUT, Ball didn't hit bat
India lost review also and Glenn Philips is still playing!!
ABSOLUTE JOKE. कट्टर INDIA समर्थक (@KKRWeRule) November 19, 2026
It was clear out. Gap between bat and ball was there.... CA Anurag (@CAAnurag_) November 19, 2026
Ban this Sonic Boom technology. India got robbed, it was clearly pad first. Baba E cricket (@BabaEcricket) November 19, 2026
That looked OUT! Stupid Sonic here... glad kaptaan saab discussed this with umpire
- Anurag Sinha (@anuragsinha1992) November 19, 2026
@cricbuzz Absolutely no bat involved
- Kunjan Desai (@kunjandesai009) November 19, 2026
@cricbuzz Even to naked eye there is no bat involved
- Wanderer (@DisDatNothin) November 19, 2026
@cricbuzz No bat involved actually
- Santosh (@ImSantoshKan) November 19, 2026
Meanwhile, India pacers will look to break the 173-run partnership early on Day 2 and restrict New Zealand to a manageable first-innings total, while Gill's side will aim to regain control of the contest at the Basin Reserve.
Also Read:Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips Rescue NZ vs India in Wellington
Legal Disclaimer:
MENAFN provides the
information “as is” without warranty of any kind. We do not accept any
responsibility or liability for the accuracy, content, images, videos,
licenses, completeness, legality, or reliability of the information
contained in this article. If you have any complaints or copyright issues
related to this article, kindly contact the provider above.

Comments
No comment