US Says It Wants A Palestinian State - Its Actions Say Otherwise

Latest stories

GOP attacks on Harris to go from bad to worse

Marcos Jr sets tone for epic clash with the Dutertes

Indian bureaucracy a curse on Indian democracy

Many issues would then have to be addressed by Palestinian and Israeli politicians, as well as the leaders of other countries that assist in their negotiations. The three most important would be the borders of a Palestinian state, the right of some Palestinians to return to land they were forced to flee in 1948, and the status of Jerusalem – which both Palestinians and Israelis insist must be their capital .

While the US has tried to promote negotiations leading to peace without dictating the outcome, it has long officially embraced a two-state solution. Former president Donald Trump, for instance, said in 2018 that,“I like a two-state solution. That's what I think works best ... That's my feeling.” Other presidents, like George W Bush and Barack Obama , have also tried to nudge the parties toward negotiations.

But while the American government's vision for peace includes the creation of a Palestinian state in theory, the US has repeatedly prevented attempts in the UN to elevate Palestine from its status from observer to a full member state .

That would be more than a symbolic change, as a Palestinian state would be officially recognized as a country in the eyes of the international community and that would provide it standing in other international organizations and courts.

The US blocked that from happening as recently as April 2024, when it vetoed a“resolution on Palestinian statehood” in the Security Council, which must approve new UN members.

The US is one of the five permanent members that make up the Security Council, alongside France, the United Kingdom, China and Russia. These countries each have the power to veto any declaration or statement the council tries to make – unlike the 10 other rotating council members who only get to vote.

What would a state look like?

Since reaching agreement on the borders of a Palestinian state and other issues will be so difficult, effective mediation is essential to achieving peace. The US has largely forfeited any role in that process, however, by its isolated and inconsistent position .

A White House spokesperson explained in May 2024 that the US maintains statehood should not come“through unilateral recognition,” but should instead happen“through direct negotiations between the parties.”

There are two problems with that rationale. First, 144 countries at the UN have already recognized a Palestinian state as a country , making recognition hardly unilateral. And it was the UN that created Israel in 1948.

Second, Israel currently has the most extreme, right-wing government in its history. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has long made clear that he is adamantly opposed to any Palestinian state. If he were to agree even to discuss the possibility of one, his coalition would immediately collapse, and he would be forced out of office.

In order to avoid pressure to discuss statehood, Netanyahu for years encouraged other countries to provide hundreds of millions of dollars to Hamas , knowing that the organization would never negotiate. He did that to weaken the Palestinian Authority, which governs the West Bank and is willing to talk.

A pro-Palestinian protester waves a Palestinian flag in front of the U.S. Capitol building in October 2023. Photo: Justin Sullivan / Getty Images via The Conversation The origin of inconsistency

Why then, even before the current Gaza war , has the US refused to allow a small step – recognition of a Palestinian state in the UN – toward a two-state solution, which it says is the only path to a sustainable peace? And why does the US remain in lockstep with an Israeli government that will never allow that to happen?

The explanation is simple – domestic politics.

While 89% of Jewish Americans said in April 2024 that they support Israel's reasons for fighting Hamas, the Gaza war has prompted some rifts in the Jewish-American community.