Quotes: MENA   Enter Symbol: NewsLetter: Search: advanced

Responding to US Budget Cuts for United Nations  Join our daily free Newsletter

MENAFN Press - 20/03/2017
No. of Ratings : 0
Add to Mixx!


(MENAFN Editorial)
iCrowdNewswire - Mar 20, 2017

Kul Chandra Gautam is a former UN Assistant -Secretary-General and Deputy Executive Director of the UN children's agency UNICEF

By Kul Chandra Gautam
KATHMANDU, Nepal, Mar 20 2017 (IPS)

It is in UN's long-term interest to gradually reduce its dependence on US funding and undue influence, as proposed by former Swedish Prime Minister Olof Palme

Kul Chandra Gautam

US President Donald Trump's first budget proposing a 28 percent cut in foreign aid, including drastic reduction in US funding for the United Nations has caused much alarm and anxiety among UN officials. Many enlightened Americans and other citizens of the world who believe in multilateral cooperation to tackle pressing global problems, such as poverty, population growth, climate change, peaceful resolution of conflicts and humanitarian assistance feel dismayed by Trump's nativistic 'America First' chest thumping.

But instead of lamenting and pleading for restitution of proposed cuts, friends of UN should welcome it as a strong incentive for seriously reducing the UN's over dependence and vulnerability to blackmail by US and occasionally by some other donors.

Part of the response would be for the UN to take a fresh look at a very creative proposal made by former Swedish Prime Minister Olof Palme in 1985 to significantly change the system of financing the UN that would be more sustainable as well as fair and practical.

Revisit the Olof Palme proposal

A great supporter of the UN and a true multilateralist, Olof Palme had the best interest of the UN at heart when he proposed that no member state should be asked or allowed to pay more than 10 to 12 percent of the UN's core budget. A 10 per cent cap, he reasoned, would limit the UN's political dependence on its largest contributors.

Any resulting deficit from decreasing the share of the US could easily be counter-balanced by relatively modest increases among other rich member countries. Today, many middle-income countries and even some lower middle-income countries can afford to pay more towards the UN budget than they do at present.

It is interesting to note that when the Palme proposal was floated in 1985, the US opposed it, fearing that it would lose its leverage over the UN. And other states, particularly the Europeans, balked at the proposal although the increased amounts they would have to pay would have been quite modest. One wonders how the US and other countries would react today, but I believe it is the right time now to explore such alternative.

Ideally, we should also look at some more innovative financing proposals such as the Tobin tax on currency or financial transactions, a carbon tax, taxes on the arms trade, and raising resources from the deep seas and other global commons, which are considered the common heritage of humankind.

But we know that the US and many other states are likely to oppose such schemes as most states want to safeguard their monopoly over taxing powers and will not be keen to give such authority to the UN or anyone else. This must, therefore, remain part of a longer-term agenda.

Today the financing for development landscape is changing rapidly. Many UN activities benefit from private financing and those by philanthropic foundations, NGOs, and increasingly cloud-sourcing and crowd-funding as well as different forms of public-private partnerships. Harnessing such possibilities must also be part of the new UN agenda as recognized in the context of sustainable development goals.

Current funding formula

For the past seven decades, funding for the UN's core budget and peace-keeping operations has been based on an internationally negotiated and agreed system of assessment of each member state's 'capacity to pay'.

Based on this, the US share currently comes to 22 percent of UN's regular budget and 28% of its peace keeping budget, or approximately 600 million plus 1.1billion respectively per year, for a total of 1.7 billion in absolute amount (not including voluntary contributions and membership fees for specialized agencies).

According to this formula #Japan pays 9.7 %, #China 7.9%, #Germany 6.4%, #France 4.9 %, UK 4.5% and Russia 3.1%. Permanent members of the UN Security Council pay a slightly higher percentage for the separate peace-keeping budget.

The poorest countries of the world pay 0.001%, whereas the Least Developed Countries (LDCs) have a cap of 0.01% each. Thus, very small and poor countries like Gambia, #Somalia and #Vanuatu pay about 27,000; #Nepal 162,000; #Bangladesh 270,000 and #India 20 million per year.

It should be noted that historically the US paid a much larger share of the UN's regular budget than it does today. At the time of the founding of the UN when there were only 50 member states, and most European countries were bankrupt after the Second World War, the US paid 49 percent of the UN budget.

As Europe recovered, its share was increased and the US share was decreased to 33 per cent in 1952; 30 per cent in 1957; 25 % in 1972 and the current 22%. Combining peace-keeping operations and other voluntary contributions, the US pays an average of 25 % of the UN's bills.

As the assessed contributions are mutually agreed and equitable treaty obligations, normally they can only be changed through multilateral negotiations. Sudden, arbitrary and unilateral cuts, like those proposed by President Trump are, therefore, tantamount to violation of the spirit of international treaty obligations.

Regrettably, money and military power often talk louder than democratic norms or treaty obligations in the realpolitik of international relations. Continuation of the undemocratic veto power by the five Permanent Members of the UN Security Council, a legacy of a different era, is the most glaring example of this reality.

Besides the assessed contribution for the UN's regular budget and peace-keeping operations, the Trump budget proposals pose an even bigger threat to the 'voluntary' contributions that the US makes to such UN funds and programs as the UN Population Fund, UNDP, and perhaps even UNICEF.

The threat goes beyond funding to the US backing out of some widely agreed global treaties such as the recent Paris agreement on climate change, the Conventions on the Rights of the Child, and the Convention on Elimination of Discrimination against Women.

Threats beyond Trump

Though Trump's threats and actions are intemperate and extreme, they are not unprecedented. From time to time, members of the US Congress have made threats to cut funding for various UN agencies and programs as their hobby-horse. One of the worst periods in recent memory was during 1995-2001 when Senator Jesse Helms was Chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee.

Indeed, the threat of US funding cuts has been a Damocles' sword hanging over the UN from the early days of its founding. Occasionally such threat has led to some useful reforms in the UN, including a more stringent review of its budget and operations. But more often it has led to distorting the globally agreed program priorities, and giving undue and unfair advantage to the US in appointment of high-level officials in the UN Secretariat, Specialized agencies and Funds and Programs.

To be fair, it is not only the US but several other major donors too often exert the power of their purse to influence the staffing, election outcomes and policy priorities of the UN. Sometimes even lesser powers like oil-rich #Qatar and #SaudiArabia exercise what is known as 'cheque-book diplomacy' to buy undue influence in UN reports and decision-making.

Like our national governments and other public as well as private institutions, the UN is not perfect. Those of us who have worked in the UN system would acknowledge that there certainly are many inefficiencies and waste in the UN system that need to be fixed. But big powers unilaterally flaunting their power of the purse to dictate their brand of reform will make the UN weaker, not stronger.

UN budget in perspective

The totality of the UN system's budget and expenditure for humanitarian assistance, development cooperation, peace-keeping operations, technical assistance and other essential normative functions, amount to about 48 billion per year. In the larger scheme of international finance, in a world economy of 77 trillion and global military budgets of 1.7 trillion per year, this is a modest amount to respond to the huge challenges that the UN is asked and expected to help tackle. The total UN system-wide spending annually is less than the defense budget of #India or France, and less than one month's US spending on defense.

With similar investment, bilateral aid and national budgets of much bigger proportions could hardly achieve results comparable to what the UN and international financial institutions achieve.

Wiser and more enlightened American leaders recognize this. In today's world, America cannot be a walled, fortified and prosperous island. In a world where epidemic diseases respect no boundaries, and do not need a passport or visa to travel, nor does the impact of global warming and climate change, America's security is inter-dependent on global human security. America's own military leaders argue that ruthlessly cutting foreign aid and throwing more money for the military cannot enhance America's security.

But lacking humility and sagacity, Trump and his associates seem to prefer pumping more money into the military machine. Trillions of dollars that US invested in military ventures in Iraq, #Afghanistan and elsewhere have brought little tangible benefits to the US or to world peace and security.

There is no evidence to believe that a whopping increase in the already bloated military budget, homeland security and building border walls will make America safer from terrorism or other threats to its security. Mr. Trump should listen to the wise words of fellow billionaire Bill Gates who says: 'The world will not be a safer place if the US stops helping other countries meet their people's needs'.

The UN certainly has its work cut out to reform itself constructively, and to come up with more durable and reliable funding alternatives to protect itself from the whims of future Trumps elsewhere. The visionary Olof Palme proposal can be one part of the solution along with other innovative measures that Secretary-General Antonio Guterres and his team must be contemplating.

MENAFN2003201700703403ID1095331238



About iCroudNewsWire

 


MENAFN Press




  MENA News Headlines
 Apr 24 2017 - Palestinian leader leaves KuwaitKuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) KUWAIT, April 24 (KUNA) -- Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas has left Kuwait following a two-day official visit to the country, where he held official talks ...

 Apr 24 2017 - Kuwait- Juncker congratulates Macron on victory in 1st round of electionKuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) BRUSSELS, April 24 (KUNA) -- The President of the European Commission Jean-Claude Juncker has congratulated the Centrist candidate in France's Presidential ...

 Apr 24 2017 - Kuwait- FM meets US Presidential EnvoyKuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) KUWAIT, April 24 (KUNA) -- Kuwaiti First Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Sheikh Sabah Al-Khaled Al-Hamad Al-Sabah received in his office on Monday ...

 Apr 24 2017 - Int'l pledging conf. for Yemen is priority for KuwaitKuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) GENEVA, April 24 (KUNA) -- Kuwait gives priority to a high-profile international pledging conference for Yemen in Geneva on Tuesday, a senior Kuwaiti diplomat ...

 Apr 24 2017 - Kuwait- Briefing of KUNA main news for Monday until 12:00 GMTKuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) KUWAIT -- Visiting US Special Presidential Envoy for the Global Coalition to Counter the So-called Islamic State (IS) Brett McGurk said on Monday that Kuwait's ...

 Apr 24 2017 - Kuwait- Al-Jarallah departs to Switzerland for Yemen's humanitarian conf.Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) KUWAIT, April 24 (KUNA) -- Kuwait's Deputy Foreign Minister Khaled Suleiman Al-Jarallah departed on Monday to Geneva to attend an international humanitarian ...

 Apr 24 2017 - France condemns deadly attack in AfghanistanKuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) PARIS, April 24 (KUNA) -- France on Monday condemned a major deadly "terrorist" attack in Afghanistan that killed more than 100 people and wounded many others in ...

 Apr 24 2017 - Kuwait making much headway in IT - KUNA's chief editorKuwait News Agency (KUNA)
(MENAFN - Kuwait News Agency (KUNA)) SHARM EL-SHEIKH, April 24 (KUNA) -- KUNA's Deputy Director-General for the Editorial Sector and Editor-in-Chief Saad Al-Ali on Monday said information technology ...

 Apr 24 2017 - Saudi- Foreign Minister receives Kazakhstan's CounterpartSaudi Press Agency
(MENAFN - Saudi Press Agency) Riyadh, Rajab 27, 1438, April 24, 2017, SPA -- Minister of Foreign Affairs Adel bin Ahmed Al-Jubeir received here today Kazakhstani Foreign Minister Khairat Abdul ...

 Apr 24 2017 - Saudi- World's first malaria vaccine to be tested in three African countriesSaudi Press Agency
(MENAFN - Saudi Press Agency) Johannesburg, Rajab 27, 1438, April 24, 2017, SPA -- The world's first malaria vaccine will be made available in Kenya, Malawi and Ghana starting in 2018, the World ...

more...


 





Google

 
 

Middle East North Africa - Financial Network

MENAFN News Market Data Countries Tools Section  
 

Middle East North Africa - Financial Network
Arabic MENAFN

Main News
News By Industry
News By Country

Search News
Market Indices
Quotes & Charts

Global Indices
Arab Indices

Commodoties

Oil & Energy

Currencies Cross Rates
Currencies Updates
Currency Converter

USA Stocks
Arab Stocks
 

Algeria 
Bahrain 
Egypt 
Iraq
Jordan 
Kuwait 
Lebanon
Morocco 
Oman 
Palestine
Qatar 
Saudi Arabia 
Syria
Tunisia 
UAE 
Yemen

Weather
Economic Calendar
Financial Glossary


Financial Calculators

RSS Feeds [XML]

Corporate Monitor

Events

Real Estate
Submit Your Property

Arab Research
Buy a Research

Press Releases
Submit your PR

Join Newsletters


 
© 2014 menafn.com All Rights Reserved.  Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Advertise | About MENAFN | Career Opportunities | Feedback | Help